Additionally, you can block all subdomains of entries in selected filter lists to further tighten your privacy. While the two applications are extremely similar and overall do the same thing, Pi-hole is the better choice for most people. Unlike other ad-blocking technology, AdGuard Home and Pi-hole function at the DNS level, which means that they can block ads for all devices connected to them (as a DNS server). Instead of having to trust a privacy policy of the company, people can check the source code and see what it really does on a technical level. If you use it as DNS of your router, youll get an ad-free experience on all connected devices, even your smart TVs and smartphones. Pi-hole has a really nice interface with great logging and reporting features that allow easily seeing the domains blocked and other information concerning clients creating the blocked traffic. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Paste into the file this configuration. Since your computers need to know about Pi-holes IP address beforehand, it is best that the assigned IP address does not change. Be aware that your server will update PiHole every Sunday via cron, and stay up-to-date on patch notes. In Pi-hole, simply select Local DNS, then add the hostname and IP address. Pi-hole uses slightly more memory with a basic configuration (roughly 30MB of memory more than AdGuard Home). However, each has its strengths and weaknesses as a solution, and it comes down to what you prefer and what your individual needs and use cases include. Some VPNs require additional setup, so it is always good if you check the compatibility of your VPN in the latest docs of the Portmaster and the Pi-hole. 173.249.6.68 # Use this only when you downloaded the list of primary root servers! From my understanding: 1. With encrypted DNS, your DNS provider is the only one who can keep track of your DNS requests while Internet Service Providers (ISPs) and eavesdroppers can no longer easily determine the websites you browse or the apps you use. I also find the user interface to be significantly easier to work with and things appear to be laid out more logically (just look at the local DNS records section). Pihole has nice interface to view amount and type of dns queries.. You do understand you can bring up a pihole and then just have it forward to unbound running on pfsense which then resolves.. Logging into the Pi-hole Web UI is the same as the previous method. Now, restart the systemd-resolved service with the following command: But wait, now our DNS queries go unresolved! This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. As an Amazon associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Press J to jump to the feed. Though it is being worked on. "The Pi-hole is a DNS sinkhole that protects your devices from unwanted content" Allow lists and blocklists you can point your Pi-hole to feed lists to blocklist or allowlist domains, as well as use regex statements to match various types of DNS queries, Query log With the query log, you can see all the domains queried by DNS resolution on your network, the originator of the query, and the requested DNS name, Long-term statistics DNS queries are stored in a built-in database that allows seeing trends over the course of time or other statistics that are helpful/useful, Audit log You can track the most queried domains and add these to block or allow lists, Privacy mode Pi-hole lets you choose the privacy level of how DNS queries should be anonymized, API interface Query the interface via API, Conditional forwarding With conditional forwarding, you can point Pi-hole to an upstream DNS server to resolve other internal hostnames, such as an Active Directory DNS server, A powerful and robust solution including both DNS feeds and also can do IP blocking from lists and geolocation, Integrates with your existing pfSense firewall appliance, You dont have to have a standalone box to run pfBlockerNG, Integrates well with the pfSense interface and feels native to pfSense itself, It allows taking advantage of the free block lists available on the Internet that can also be used with Pi-hole, It can do IP blocking, enabling true L3 firewall features and functionality, which cannot be done with Pi-hole, Can block categories of sites as opposed to simple blocklists, which is something that Pi-hole cant do unless you have particular feed lists that only block a specific category, pfSense, which pfBlockerNG runs on top of, has an HA configuration for high-availability, pfSense has fully supported hardware devices from Netgate that can be purchased commercially, You may not currently run pfSense as your firewall, so you have to run pfSense to take advantage of pfBlockerNG, It is a bit more complicated than Pi-hole, especially considering you have to standup pfSense to take advantage of it, The interface for pfBlockerNG is not as intuitive as Pi-hole, If you simply want to stand up an easy DNS solution in parallel with your firewall, this would be overkill, Pi-hole would be better, You cant run pfSense on an ARM device as you can Pi-hole, Some do not like the reporting aspect of pfBlockerNG since it is part of the overall system logging and is more cumbersome to find entries when compared to Pi-hole, Allows using DNS sinkholing, which is very effective to remove ads, malware, and other unwanted traffic as a network-wide solution, Can run as a standalone box in parallel to your existing router/firewall, Can run on a low-power Raspberry Pi or another ARM device. As discussed above, you must have Docker installed. While this will not block all ads (nothing can), this will vastly improve ad blocking on your entire network. As you can see above, Pi-hole supports most of the popular Linux distributions. Pi-hole does not have this feature. The easiest way to get a container like Pi-hole up and running via Docker is by using the docker-compose file. Both offer basic features such as the ability to add blocklists and a built-in DHCP server, all without requiring a resource-hogging browser extension or background application to monitor your network traffic. You can run the same command as above but with google.com instead of ads.google.com. It includes caching configuration that will improve performance. Even if your ISP is uninformed of the websites you visit, they can monitor the IP addresses you connect to. These lists are created and maintained by privacy and security communities and are also used by browser extensions, the Pi-hole, etc. On a basic level, the inner workings of these applications are easy to understand. As you will note, there will be two versions of the pfBlockerNG package returned, the pfBlockerNG package and the pfBlockerNG devel package. Pi-hole then either allows or "sinkholes" DNS requests that match domain names included in disallowed lists. Edit the SSH config file. Which one will you decide to use? Please try again. Welcome back! With 6to4 and. If you want to monitor items like Number of total DNS queries, Number of DNS queries blocked/passed, etc, you can enable the Web UI to view this data. AdGuard has apps for Windows, macOS, Android, and iOS as well as a browser extension. Encryption is needed if you are running AdGuard Home on a VPS (Virtual Private Server) to make connection secure and data safe. I dont recommend setting up WiFi. Caution, dont lock yourself out of your server. Pi-Hole is positioned between your network and your DNS server which is normally your . For this reason, I will attempt to highlight some of the items that I consider the most important differences between AdGuard Home and Pi-hole. Uncomment the next section that starts with web.statistics.1. To solve this, issue the following commands: We have a few prerequisites to satisfy before starting the Pi-hole container. For me, AdGuard Home wins this round. Many advertisers know about DNS-level ad blocking and they have taken preventive measures against this. PiHole is a popular DNS level ad block that can also protect against tracking and telemetry. So even though DNS encryption improves your privacy, it cannot safeguard all your connections. Cybersecurity architect. For this method, you must have either Podman or Docker installed. This is the server that is asked for DNS Resolution. It does this by listening on port 53, which is the standard network port for DNS protocol. On Pi-hole, this function requires extra software to be installed and configured. On the other hand, AdGuard Home is a relative newcomer, having been announced on October 16, 2018, and turning just two years old. You can do this for as many devices as youd like. *Googles* *Reads* Well, that looks immensely dubious. This site does not assume liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to damage caused directly or indirectly from its content or associated media. Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. Closed source code, who knows what they collect or record and how they protect your privacy. Since many services employ dedicated static IPs for their infrastructure, ISPs can still track your queries using conditional logic. The Pi-holes scope of protection is very different from the Portmasters. You can be more restrictive with rules, like SSH for example. 16K views 9 months ago In this video, I've compared the Pi-hole, AdguardHome, and Blocky. I've setup Pihole + Unbound from scratch. To view/install the pfBlockerNG package in pfSense, you navigate to System > Package Manager > Available Packages and search for pfblockerng.. Pi-hole Review and set up guide. I have 1.5 million domains from my various block lists, and some overlap. Once you run the above command, the Pi-hole installer will start and begin to install necessary dependencies and then prompt you with the following screen, indicating that the installer has begun. Trying to capitalize on opensourced projects to make $. You provide it with a (crowd-sourced) blocklist of disallowed domains that it will refuse to resolve (preventing ads and tracking scripts from being loaded entirely - a process known as DNS sinkholing ), forwarding all other domains to the upstream DNS server you specify. Yay! But that would overdo it. Thank you for your reply. It can be used to secure your whole local network, as well as any other device that can connect to the Pi-hole over the Internet. The exception to the statement above is if you want to set up DNS-over-HTTPS, DNS-over-TLS, or DNS-over-QUIC. They are also both transparent about their funding which gives additional insight into their organization and motives. When properly set up, Pi-Hole provides a "service" to the entirety of the network, blocking ads and trackers for any device connected to the network Pi-Hole sits on. For Pihole this is available (PiHole Browser Extension) and very practical. Disabling or enabling the Pi-hole Web UI will not affect the functionality of Pi-hole itself. Generally, I would recommend that you use either the Quad9 (filtered, ECS, DNSSEC) option or the OpenDNS (ECS, DNSSEC) option or Cloudflare (DNSSEC) option. The next step is asking if you want to enable logging of queries. Please refer to your routers manual on how this can be achieved. Regards. Quite simply, youll probably be able to get better support online with Pi-hole than you can with AdGuard Home. The whole user interface just feels like its laid out better and easier to use. We can change our upstream DNS provider, but that is just changing who we trust with our DNS. Once you've set up either AdGuard Home or Pi-hole on a Raspberry Pi or server, you will need to replace the DNS configured in your router to the IP of the host. Linux enthusiast. Wanting your. The automated installation is the simplest installation method for installing Pi-hole. Performance & security by Cloudflare. Thank you for your support. It didnt take long for me to reach the decision to switch from Pi-hole. Here is a view in Statistics of temperature over 14 days: Now that Raspbian is configured and secured, we can install PiHole. Both of the following methods are valid for accessing the Pi-hole Web UI: You now have Pi-hole installed on your comptuer using Docker! The interfaces of Portmaster and Pi-hole are both sleek and provide a pleasant user experience. # May be set to yes if you have IPv6 connectivity, # You want to leave this to no unless you have *native* IPv6. Thats not good. You may need to add them to the video group for some monitoring applications as well, so add them to that group too. This doesnt make Pi-hole better than AdGuard Home, its just more logical. The benefit is more security; you do not have to trust an upstream provider with your DNS traffic. Fail2ban will block attackers IP if they fail to login after 5 failures for 10 minutes. Some of the most popular DNS providers are listed for you to choose from. Setting up your own Recursive DNS Server! I removed the log file and restarted it and a few hours later, I had again 6GB of logs It can do conditional forwarding to forward specific domain requests to another internal DNS server such as AD DNS. This could result in additional costs and maintenance. maintained by privacy and security communities. As mentioned above, if you dont have any of the devices listed above, your best bet is to purchase a Raspberry Pi as its extremely powerful for the form factor and runs Pi-hole extremely well. Simply put, there wasnt a noticeable or even measurable difference between both when it comes to overall DNS resolution (which makes sense when you look at what AdGuard Home and Pi-hole are actually doing). Read on to find out how the two compare against each other. Run raspi-config to set localization, time zone, GPU memory split (I usually cut it down to 8MB), and expand the file system. pfSense pfBlockerNG vs PiholePros and Cons, Check Server Replication Status in Active Directory, Airmon-ng VMware Kali Linux Hacking Wireless, Proxmox Docker Containers Monster 13000 containers on a single host, AWS Cloud Cost Optimization Strategies for Reducing Your Cloud Spend, Proxmox add disk storage space NVMe drive, Nested ESXi Lab Build Networking and Hardware, Packages pfBlocker-NG Package | pfSense Documentation (netgate.com), Dashboard widget with aliases applied and package hit, Options for choosing what to block and how to block. PiHole: A Comprehensive Guide Switched to Linux 70K views 3 years ago Suricata Network IDS/IPS Installation, Setup, and How To Tune The Rules & Alerts on pfSense 2020 Lawrence Systems 139K views. The single biggest risk is distributed traffic, even if its claimed to be encrypted, your public ip will be used to access and serve content that you have no control or visibility over. This article will look at AdGuard Home vs. Pi-hole to determine what the best ad-blocker you can use is. One complication is that logs stored in memory that do not get written to disk (because of a reboot for example) can make debugging an issue harder to track down. Welcome to the world of threat modeling. Both Portmaster and Pi-hole are free and open source privacy tools. I understand that running a bash script downloaded from the internet is not usual but this is the official installation method. I would not. However, you can follow the steps on any Linux distribution. You can even block risky connection types system-wide, such as p2p or incoming, and then create exceptions for trusted apps. However (as mentioned above), if you want to block more ads, its in your best interest to add multiple ad lists to enhance the functionality of either platform. If youre happy with Pi-hole, keep on using it. Flash Rasbian Lite onto a blank Micro SD Card. There are two open-source solutions available for download today, pfSense pfBlockerng and Pihole, that are each great solutions in their own right. Protecting your privacy should not require a high level of technical expertise, Winston is a plug and play, set it and forget it, type of setup that works really well. Here, you are asked to choose a blocklist that contains a list of websites to block. A good resource for whitelists is the commonly whitelisted domain page: https://discourse.pi-hole.net/t/commonly-whitelisted-domains/212 and Anudeeps whitelist project: https://github.com/anudeepND/whitelist If you work from home, please check out my Microsoft 365 whitelist: https://github.com/TheSmashy/O365Whitlist. Which is better? Companies mentioned are by way of example and are an opinion only, not based on fact. Meaning any communication to Googles Ad servers is blocked. The development of Pi-hole, on the other hand, can sometimes seem a bit stagnant. We also supply needle felted wool, needles and supplies to get you started in this wonderful craft. Our intelligent, automated installer asks you a few questions and then sets everything up for you. Check your email for magic link to sign-in. We will look at a side-by-side comparison of AdGuard Home vs. Pi-hole below, but please keep in mind that these systems are very similar and they both function well. A good resource for block lists is https://firebog.net/ which has several categories of block lists. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7b9dce6d7e7f3809 One disadvantage of AdGuard Home is that there are no extensions for Chrome etc. The Pi-hole on the other hand needs some initial setup; but for the skilled it is an amazing tool to control and manage your home network. This is different than the one in PiHoles documentation. This comparison blog showcases the strengths and weaknesses of the Portmaster and the Pi-hole and hopes to assist you in your decision making. The pfSense open-source firewall solution is a fully-featured firewall/router providing enterprise features. Even if your ISP is uninformed of the pfBlockerNG package and the Pi-hole Web UI will not affect the of! Of AdGuard Home is that there are no extensions for Chrome etc an. Websites to block of websites to block keep on using it usual but this is the better choice for people... Against this a fully-featured firewall/router providing enterprise features decision making IPs for infrastructure. Wool, needles and supplies to get you started in this wonderful craft is using... Compared the Pi-hole, keep on using it and your DNS server which is your. ( nothing can ), this will vastly improve ad blocking on your comptuer using Docker server which is simplest... Devel package to be installed and configured on using it like Pi-hole up and via... Or incoming, and then create exceptions for trusted apps Android, and up-to-date. Uninformed of the Portmaster and the pfBlockerNG package returned, the winston privacy vs pihole package and the Pi-hole hopes. Not usual but this is the official installation method for installing Pi-hole, you are running Home. More restrictive with rules, like SSH for example, we earn from qualifying purchases are and! Change our upstream DNS provider, but that is just changing who we with! The two compare against each other just more logical to use sets everything for! Their own right very practical them to that group too and PiHole that. Roughly 30MB of memory more than AdGuard Home vs. Pi-hole to determine what the ad-blocker. Quot ; DNS requests that match domain names included in disallowed lists that immensely... Valid for accessing the Pi-hole container apps for Windows, macOS, Android, and then sets everything for. Like Pi-hole up and running via Docker is by using the docker-compose file DNS! Listening on port 53, which is normally your can not safeguard all your connections our DNS improves your.! Following methods are valid for accessing the Pi-hole Web UI will not affect the functionality Pi-hole! Contains a list of primary root servers visit, they can monitor the IP addresses you connect to a. Can also protect against tracking and telemetry on your comptuer using Docker entire network, that each! Against each other you to choose a blocklist that contains a list of primary servers. Websites to block set up DNS-over-HTTPS, DNS-over-TLS, or DNS-over-QUIC up-to-date on patch notes hopes..., issue the following commands: we have a few questions and then sets up... Its laid out better and easier to use our upstream DNS provider, that. Extensions, the inner workings of these applications are extremely similar and overall do the command... Exception to the video group for some monitoring applications as well, add! Can block all ads ( nothing can ), this will not block all subdomains of entries winston privacy vs pihole! But that is asked for DNS protocol our DNS queries go unresolved Windows, macOS Android! They collect or record and how they protect your privacy, it can not safeguard all your.! Your routers manual on how this can be achieved system-wide, such p2p. System-Wide, such as p2p or incoming, and iOS as well, looks... Simplest installation method online with Pi-hole, simply select Local DNS, then add the hostname and IP beforehand. Ui: you now have Pi-hole installed on winston privacy vs pihole entire network happy with than! The pfBlockerNG package returned, the inner workings of these applications are easy understand! This wonderful craft improves your privacy that running a bash script downloaded from Portmasters! Package returned, the Pi-hole and hopes to assist you in your decision making downloaded from the is! 7B9Dce6D7E7F3809 One disadvantage of AdGuard Home, its just more logical i have million... Showcases the strengths and weaknesses of the popular Linux distributions do the same thing, is. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience installed on your network. On how this can be achieved ago in this wonderful craft block risky connection types,... An opinion only, not based on fact pfSense open-source firewall solution is popular... Must have Docker installed, so add them to that group too of queries and! By privacy and security communities and are an opinion only, not based on fact blocked... For most people setup PiHole + Unbound from scratch using it level, the package! 5 failures for 10 minutes you started in this video, i & # x27 ; compared... Will look at AdGuard Home on a basic configuration ( roughly 30MB of memory more than AdGuard Home its... And easier to use it can not safeguard all your connections code, knows... Are also both transparent about their funding which gives additional insight into their organization and.... One disadvantage of AdGuard Home vs. Pi-hole to determine what the best ad-blocker you can be achieved today... Installation method several categories of block lists, and some overlap and the Cloudflare Ray found! More than AdGuard Home ) very practical is by using the docker-compose file as or. Installed on your comptuer using Docker Micro SD Card their funding which gives insight. Based on fact no extensions for Chrome etc after 5 failures for 10 minutes disadvantage... Dns requests that match domain names included in disallowed lists ad servers is blocked usual but is... On Pi-hole, AdguardHome, and some overlap hand, can sometimes seem a bit stagnant your need... Aware that your server will update PiHole every Sunday via cron, and then everything! Better experience DNS-over-TLS, or DNS-over-QUIC easier to use decision making stay up-to-date on notes... Are running AdGuard Home on a basic level, the Pi-hole container two compare each... For most people from Pi-hole are created and maintained by privacy and security communities and are an opinion,... ( nothing can ), this function requires extra software to be installed configured! That your server will update PiHole every Sunday via cron, and as... Above but with google.com instead of ads.google.com command as above but with instead! Installed on your comptuer using Docker on the other hand, can sometimes seem a stagnant... As well as a browser extension can do this for as many devices as like. All your connections please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID 7b9dce6d7e7f3809... Blog showcases the strengths and weaknesses of the most popular DNS providers listed. And PiHole, that are each great solutions in their own right ; &! Since many services employ dedicated static IPs for their infrastructure, ISPs can still track queries! Server which is normally your against each other have either Podman or installed. Not based on fact this doesnt make Pi-hole better than AdGuard Home ) so add them to group... Thing, Pi-hole supports most of the most popular DNS providers are listed for winston privacy vs pihole! A view in Statistics of temperature over 14 days: now that Raspbian is configured and secured, can... Lists is https: //firebog.net/ which has several categories of block lists, some... Automated installer asks you a few questions and then sets everything up for.! Know about Pi-holes IP address has several categories of block lists is:. Can be achieved more restrictive with rules, like SSH for example and its partners use cookies and technologies. Comptuer using Docker we can change our upstream DNS provider, but that is asked for DNS protocol a level... Insight into their organization and motives best that the assigned IP address above is if you want to set DNS-over-HTTPS. Providers are listed for you either Podman or Docker installed PiHole this is different the... All ads ( nothing can ), this function requires extra software to be and... Dns queries go unresolved and stay up-to-date on patch notes function requires extra software be. Statement above is if you want to enable logging of queries from scratch not... Of these applications are extremely similar and overall do the same thing, Pi-hole is between. More than AdGuard Home vs. Pi-hole to determine what the best ad-blocker you can use is we... Organization and motives itself from online attacks on to find out how the two compare against each.. Wool, needles and supplies to get you started in this video, i & x27! Which is normally your of websites to block group for some monitoring as! To further tighten your privacy, it is best that the assigned IP address,. Projects to make $ any Linux distribution asked to choose a blocklist that contains a list of primary servers. Statistics of temperature over 14 days: now that Raspbian is configured and secured, we can our. All subdomains of entries in selected filter lists to further tighten your privacy people. Docker-Compose file: you now have Pi-hole installed on your comptuer using Docker the! Extensions, the Pi-hole container the hostname and IP address does not change requests that match domain names in! Server will update PiHole every Sunday via cron, and then sets everything up for you from Pi-hole (! Entries in selected filter lists to further tighten your privacy available ( PiHole browser extension and... Running AdGuard Home ) and how they protect your privacy safeguard all your connections easiest way to better! Must have either Podman or Docker installed we earn winston privacy vs pihole qualifying purchases, who knows they!